Talk:Alice/@comment-30688411-20161207031955/@comment-26097222-20161209222019

Depends on the laws where it happened and the actual chronological age of the Alice. If she's actually 12 is the simplest scenario. Two twelve year olds having sex in parts of Mexico and some states in the USA (Washington or Colorado for example) it would be perfectly legal. In other places (California or Wisconsin for example) they would both be considered the victims of rape and each could be prosecuted for raping the other -- consent or lack ofit would be irrelevant under the law. California has a little sanity (not much) in this and sets the maximum sentence at a year in juenile prison. Wisconsin (the place with the strictest sex laws in North America) has no such sanity check, and each could wind up spending as much as 10-20 years in prison. Yes, both of them. But Alices stop physically aging at some point and that girl who looks like she is 10 might actually be 40. Or 400. The mental age doesn't particularly matter for age-based age of consent laws, a 40 year old Alice seducing a 12 year old boy wouldn't be legally any different than a 40 year old human woman doing it. If caught in a modern setting, she is going to prison. There is also reduced capacity and mind alteration to consider. Having sex with someone who is mentally incompetent is considered rape almost everywhere in a modern settings, regardless of the nature of the incompetence. An Alice confuses things since while she looks like the victim of repeated rapes, she is actually the rapist given her use of charm magic to force men to attack her. Using charm magic on someone would legally be no different than using roofies. In a medieval setting, age of consent and the minimum age you could be sentenced to execution for a crime were linked -- people younger than 7 years old were considered innocent children, those older than 7 had the same responsibilities adults did. So two 12 year olds in a medieval European setting would be perfectly legal.