Talk:The Order/@comment-25409001-20150715033458/@comment-25035274-20150715132018

1) "This should be impossible."

I'm not seeing your flow of logic. Why is it impossible that this is the first time a monster decided to try to make nice with the humans? Give a concrete, fact based answer, please; not an opinion or a "if I were writing the story" answer. Similarly, please explain why there must have, by necessity, been a time when every other type of monster was in power.

I say this because it doesn't logically flow from Point A to Point B. "There have been multiple Demon Lords" does not connect to "So every type of monster must have had a Demon Lord at some point, probably even multiple times." It just doesn't. There's no connection there.

There's more logical reasoning to believe that this 'is' the first time: (a) There's been no evidence to support a belief that there have been multiple rebellions; (b) Given the innate nature of non-mamono monsters (see their traditional depictions: violent and predatory), any previous "rebellions" would have been far more likely to be bloody rather than sexy; and (c) the end-all meta excuse - KC says so.

2) "The monster attacks, this happens when humans become too advance* in which monsters become suddenly powerful and aggresive and are lead by the Demon Lord of that time."

"I don't think the CG is trying to hold back humanity, more or less trying to prevent them from going into a time where they might forget that there are monsters that lurk in the shadows. The smarter you become, the sceptical you are. So if humans become more and more smarter than they might try to prove the monsters don't exist and would birth a time where humans don't believe in monsters. This might cause the humans to be woefully underprepared when the mosnters suddenly do attack and kill every human in a plaza."

Your second statement would make far more sense if not for the fact that you made the first. In the first, you acknowledge that these attacks are always timed for when humanity is at its most advanced cultural level, suggesting that the intention IS, in fact, to prevent humanity from advancing beyond some arbitrary, pre-defined level.

This is actually a somewhat common theme in anime/manga. It is, for instance, THE central theme of the Legends series of the Mega Man franchise, where-in the planet's human (or carbon) population is regularly blasted back to the Stone Age whenever they start to reach too great a number. This is not, it should be noted, an attempt at 'protecting' the humans. It's the attempt of a maniacal AI to keep control over a naturally chaotic system.